Authenticity and Wellness

In a 2024 article in the magazine Philosophy Now, author and former philosophy teacher Paul Doolan attacks the wellness industry for its inauthenticity. He writes, “The wellness and anti-aging industry, the obsession with physical health and youthfulness, all deny death and are flights from authenticity, even while adapting the language of authenticity.” As someone concerned with wellness and tangentially connected with the wellness industry, I take issue with this claim. In this article, I unpack Doolan’s argument and share my understanding of wellness, an understanding informed by prominent philosophical figures like those Doolan cites. In doing so, I argue that we should prioritize wellness over authenticity when wellness leads to broader goods like moral behavior and psychological health.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Jean-Jacques Rousseau

What Does It Mean to Be Authentic?

Authenticity According to Rousseau

Doolan never explicitly defines authenticity in his article. Instead, he cites philosophical accounts related to authenticity, without fully endorsing any of them. On Swiss philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, he writes:

“[Rousseau] argued that an exclusive emphasis on reason estranges us from reality, alienates us from our fundamental selves, and leads to artifice and hypocrisy. Natural man, exemplified for Rousseau by the Noble Savage, possessed an authentic goodness. We fallen civilised creatures can only hope to regain authenticity by turning our backs on the chattering classes of the metropolitan salons and by immersing ourselves in nature, for instance, by taking a long hike in the woods or mountains.”

According to Doolan’s account of Rousseau, authenticity means harkening back to our pre-social ancestors, perhaps by reducing our reliance on reason and by living more fully in nature.

Authenticity According to Heidegger

Doolan then expands on Rousseau’s argument with help from German philosopher Martin Heidegger: “One of Martin Heidegger’s key insights was that being human means being-in-the-world” (Doolan’s emphasis). Doolan adds:

“[Heidegger] argued that we are often caught up in a state he calls ‘fallen’ or ‘ensnared’: we fall into the chatter of everyday life, with its constant worries and anxieties, but this leads us to stray from the essence of what it really means to be an authentic human being.”

One prominent anxiety humans try to avoid is the knowledge that we will die. For Heidegger,

“To anticipate one’s death is to be authentic: to be fully aware that my own death is a certainty, that it can occur at any time, and is therefore always just before me – this heightened awareness reveals my authentic self. Otherwise I am living in denial, and, so, am inauthentic.”

Here, Doolan takes specific aim at wellness enthusiasts, writing that their obsession with physical health and youthfulness leads them to deny death and merely pretend to authenticity. In other words, wellness and longevity enthusiasts imagine they can live forever. But immortality is, of course, impossible. Therefore, wellness enthusiasts are chasing a delusion, causing their efforts to lack authenticity.

In summary, authenticity for Doolan involves recognizing that we are human beings who will die and who got on just fine without society and all its associated pressures and anxieties. We can live authentic lives by returning to that state of nature existence and facing the unartificial reality surrounding us—a reality that includes death. However, I’m not convinced that authenticity precludes physical wellness, nor that we ought to prioritize authenticity above other considerations.

Rousseau on Authenticity and Wellness

The State of Nature

Let’s start with Rousseau. As Doolan says, Rousseau decried the modern emphasis on reason over physicality. In his Discourse on Inequality, Rousseau wrote, “As the savage man’s body is the only instrument he knows, he puts it to various uses for which our bodies, through lack of exercise, are unfit, and it is our industry which deprives us of the strength and agility that necessity obliges him to acquire.” [1] He argued that humans in a pre-social state of nature could hold their own against predators, rarely suffered diseases and mostly died of old age.

I remain skeptical of Rousseau’s overall assertion that humans in a pre-social state of nature lived longer, healthier lives than their modern, socialized descendants. Human life expectancy has steadily increased century after century. Chimpanzees (humanity’s closest genetic relative) in captivity generally outlive their wild counterparts. That’s not to say that we should trade freedom for captivity, but simply further evidence against Rousseau’s state of nature claims. Modern shelters, sanitation and medicine have drastically reduced human mortality rate. At the same time, Rousseau was onto something three centuries ago. In our contemporary world, increasingly sedentary lifestyles and the ready availability of hyper-palatable, calorie-dense, nutrient-poor foods have led to a rise in chronic health conditions like obesity, cardiovascular disease and metabolic dysfunction. As Dr. Peter Attia puts it, modern medicine excels at extending human lifespan but falls short at improving healthspan.

Modern Wellness

Many wellness advocates make essentially the same claims about modern society that Rousseau did. It’s hard to imagine Rousseau would oppose basic wellness guidelines like moving more and shifting our diets to moderate quantities of nutrient-dense foods. Here, I expect Doolan would push back and say that hitting the gym four times a week and meal-prepping in a well-appointed, climate-controlled kitchen is not the same as early humans foraging for food, chasing down prey, carrying their infants and climbing trees to escape predators. Our human ancestors, Doolan might argue, were living authentic lives because their natural environment compelled them to be physically active and consume nourishing foods. Modern health-conscious lifestyles are hollow forgeries of our ancestors fully immersed in nature.

Doolan may have a point. Doing pull-ups on a $2,000 cable machine in an air-conditioned gym isn’t the same thing as clambering up a tree before the lion gets its jaws around your leg. But here I’m forced to ask, how important is authenticity? Surely, maintaining a regular exercise routine and eating store-bought vegetables every day is a better option than living a sedentary, junk food-fueled lifestyle. Does it matter for your physical health or for how you treat others that you aren’t fully embracing the physical and psychological challenges of living unmediated in nature?

A woman doing pull-ups next to the produce section of a grocery store, highlighting the contrast between authenticity and wellness

Heidegger, Death and Existentialism

All of that brings us to Heidegger. To a certain extent, his views on death are shared by other existentialist philosophers. Death is an inescapable reality. One day, our corporeal bodies will cease to function. Depending on your beliefs about the afterlife, death may also be the end for your mind, soul or whatever non-physical self exists. In Doolan’s words, this awareness of death reveals the authentic self. But more is required than simply acknowledging the certainty of death. Until the moment death takes us, we are free to choose how we conduct our lives. For existentialist philosophers, human existence is a constant struggle to make meaning in a universe that will ultimately see us obliterated and forgotten. But to evade that struggle, to pretend that our imminent death or our mortal circumstances limit our freedom, is to live in “bad faith,” in the words of existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre.

So yes, to pretend death does not exist is to engage in self-deception. But being authentic by acknowledging death’s certainty should not be the ultimate goal. Rather, we should seek to live meaningful lives in the finite time we have. It’s not clear to me how wellness advocates evade this search for meaning. If our existential clock is always ticking, wouldn’t it be better to spend that time healthy, vibrant and capable rather than weak and sickly? Wouldn’t improving one’s physical capabilities and extending one’s lifespan open more options to find meaning? As I have previously argued here and here, physical health provides more opportunities to live a meaningful, ethical life—no matter your specific ethical beliefs.

What Does It Mean to Be Well?

Now maybe this is how Doolan sees the wellness industry, as a social media-fueled quest toward physical perfection that involves multiple icy face plunges and no human contact aside from the servant cleaning up your broken water bottle and peeling the banana you don’t eat. But to put everyone who cares about physical wellness in that basket is a gross overgeneralization. (And if you find your life of alternating sprints with ice baths and banana peel rubs meaningful, who am I to say you’re wrong?)

In the words of quasi-existentialist philosopher Albert Camus, “There is but one truly serious philosophical problem, and that is suicide.” With death ever bearing down on us, we must constantly choose to live with the burden of freedom and the acknowledgment of our finitude or succumb to hopelessness and despair. Doing so requires a physical engagement with the world. Physical wellness is one way we can say yes to life and fight against the inevitable decay and destruction of old age and death.

Maybe the choices we make in pursuit of wellness aren’t as authentic as those of early humans. But who cares? Given the choice, we would all prefer health over illness, strength over infirmity, vitality over lethargy. Being well and being authentic are not mutually exclusive. But we should prioritize the quality that offers the best outcomes across all spheres of life.


1. Ritter, Alan and Julia Conaway Bondanella, eds. Rousseau’s Political Writings. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1988, p. 11.